NCLB. Don’t Tell Me the Problem, I Need the Solution.

Tags: , ,

I want to go on record as saying (or typing) that No Child Left Behind may not be the evil monster it is portrayed to be.

Do I like all aspects of the law? No.

Do I think it is a daily aggravation hanging over educator’s heads? Yes.

Does it carry any real weight? I don’t think anyone knows as of yet.NCLB Isn't All Bad.

Do I completely understand all of the details of the law? Probably not (but I am no more confused by it then I am; marriage, car engines, health insurance, how microwaves work, or why humans find reality shows on VH1 interesting).

What I do understand is that every profession needs rules and guidelines to encourage employees to do their best.

Without expectations it becomes easy to do an adequate job, but not a great one. When it comes to students, I think we can all agree that no one wants to settle for adequate, when great is always possible.

Everyone in education (and outside of education) understandably works harder when they are pushed to achieve more than they think possible.

It is human nature for people to rise or fall to the level of expectations. Some people are self motivated enough not to need the occasional push, but most of us are not.

When I was a kid, it didn’t take me long to figure out that I did a better job mowing the yard when I knew my dad would check on my work when I finished. I am not sure how much effort I would have put into the yard work if I knew there weren’t going to be consequences when I was done.

America is a results-based country. Athletic contests are based on who scores the most points (one reason we hate soccer… not enough points). Salespeople get paid bonuses for production. Politicians are elected by the most votes (sorry Mr. Gore, I know it still hurts). And as educators we give out grades every day.

Meeting goals and being evaluated is our way of life. Those who produce, get rewarded, and those who don’t, get passed by.

In a sentence, NCLB basically says schools have to improve themselves, or the government will come in and do it for them (technically, if it was that easy wouldn’t the government just improve them from the start?).

I understand that educators don’t want to be mandated standards that they feel are unreachable. This also makes sense to me, but yet I have never heard a counter proposal on how schools and teachers should be judged (Technically, if fixing NCLB/schools was that easy wouldn’t educators come up with adjustments to fix them, or have a plan to entirely overhaul the present system?).

Lots of people are good at pointing out problems, but it is so much harder to come up with a solution.

I try to understand the high expectations NCLB is placing on us. As a citizen, I certainly want and expect the highest (even unreachable) standards for other professions such as; airplane mechanics, construction workers, surgeons, firefighters, and fast food cooks.

You may be asking yourself, “Why did he mention fast food cooks?” Use your head people.

Administrators are Enemy #1 for high school kids as you pick up your food at the drive thru window (mental note; do not purchase fast food within 18 miles of your office desk … it is not worth the risk).

We need the highest standards possible for these angry 17 year olds working at Taco Bell (and constant video surveillance if possible).

But back to the expectations of NCLB.

Every occupation needs laws and regulations to govern them. In education we may feel overwhelmed by the federal law hanging over our heads, but I am sure Doug Heffernan had rules at IPS that he didn’t agree with (Google alert).

My point is NCLB is not the greatest law I have ever seen, but education does need rules and guidelines to follow so that all teachers and administrators work to their fullest potential, so students can reach theirs.

The only question I have left is with the War in Iraq, a possible recession, a mortgage crisis, immigration issues, terrorism, and gas prices skyrocketing… who takes over for President Bush if he doesn’t meet or exceed?

Tags: , ,

5 Responses to “NCLB. Don’t Tell Me the Problem, I Need the Solution.”


  1. Angie
    on Jan 25th, 2008
    @ 1:47 pm

    I agree that we should have standards to reach. But the problem with standardized testing is realism. For the TAKS test, “they” expect a 5th grader with a 3rd grade reading level to take the 5th grade test. “They” expect a student who is taking a science test in Spanish to have a higher passing rate than a student who takes the same test in English. Our TAKS test scores are based on 11th grade tests, but AYP is based on 10th grade. And why is the standard based on one class of kids compared to a totally different class? The standards should be based on improvement, not some unrealistic ideal that 100% of students will be passing a test in 5 years. Sure it’s great to have the goal, but, if you’re tying money to it, then let’s be realistic.


  2. Jen
    on Jan 25th, 2008
    @ 3:07 pm

    Yeah, comparing each kid to him/herself seems a lot smarter way of doing it, rather than this year’s kids to last year’s kids.

    At least a year’s worth of progress from wherever you started (it would help kids that are ahead then, too!). Kids that are months to years behind to start with? Concentrate your special services there. Have some sort of freeform K-1 classes that you get out of when you’re at grade level to begin 2nd grade.


  3. If I Write a Blog About Politicians, Do You Think My Chances of Getting Audited Go Up or Down? | PrincipalsPage The Blog
    on Jun 14th, 2009
    @ 8:28 am

    [...] it comes to education, politicians continually have brainstorms on how it can be improved. This is fine with me because as an educator I believe we need to be [...]


  4. The School Administrators Arch Nemisis. | PrincipalsPage The Blog
    on Jul 18th, 2009
    @ 7:17 am

    [...] Principals and Superintendents seem especially likely to attract people or things that don’t like them. [...]


  5. Turns Out the Soccer Gods May Get the Last Laugh. | PrincipalsPage The Blog
    on Jul 18th, 2009
    @ 7:40 am

    [...] has decided that we are going to spend our weekends at the local YMCA participating in an indoor soccer [...]

Leave a Reply

Disclaimer

While this site operates with the knowledge and awareness of the Tuscola CUSD #301 School Board, Tuscola, Illinois, the content and opinions posted here may or may not represent their views personally or collectively, nor does it attempt to represent the official viewpoint of Tuscola CUSD #301 administrators or employees.